top of page

The Myth of "Do Anything" Solutions: When One Size Fits None

One System to Rule Them All!


In the evolving world of enterprise operational software, the lure of a single system that can "do it all" is as enticing as misleading. The ERP systems of today, like SAP, Oracle, or Microsoft Dynamics, promise to manage everything from warehouse operations to procurement, finance, and production. The appeal of such comprehensive "Do Anything" solutions is obvious—a single interface, a single source of truth, and a unified software ecosystem that should make everything run smoothly. But for many businesses, the reality falls far short of the ideal, often resulting in a tangled mess of inefficiencies, frustrations, and enormous financial waste.


Take, for example, the world of warehouse management. ERP systems were designed to handle broad business operations like financial reporting and supply chain oversight, but now they're being asked to manage warehouse inventory and operations, a realm with unique needs. This mismatch is like trying to use a chainsaw to peel an apple—it's powerful but unsuited for the delicate and specific nature of the task at hand. The need for specialized systems becomes even more apparent in industries like paper and fiber production and waste and scrap recycling. Trying to use a generalized ERP solution to control the intricacies of material handling or chemical processes often leads to inflexible configurations, a nightmare of workarounds, and systems that are ultimately unable to fulfill the basic needs for which they were implemented.


Recipe for Disaster

One notable example is a global recycling company that invested millions of dollars into an ERP solution, believing it could handle the intricacies of scrap material procurement and yard inventory management. What they ended up with was a system that required extensive customizations just to approximate the functionality they needed, introducing operational inefficiencies, astronomical consulting costs, and perpetual licensing fees. Worse yet, the system never truly fit their business model, and employees had to resort to spreadsheets and manual processes—undermining the very purpose of the ERP investment.


The allure of a one-system-to-rule-them-all approach is understandable. But it's a unicorn—a mythical promise that seems too good to be true because it is. Today's Businesses need to move away from these monolithic solutions, which "do everything but nothing great," and instead embrace a new vision: enterprise platforms built for integration from the ground up. Systems that allow companies to leverage best-in-class solutions across each of their specialized functions—warehouse management, procurement, finance, CRM, and more—in an architecture that brings it all together.


A Way Forward

Modern enterprise solutions aren’t monolithic. They’re composable and modular—built with integration in mind. The core characteristics of such platforms include Event-Driven Architecture (EDA) for real-time communication between services, drag-and-drop workflow management to create and adapt business rules, and a plug-and-play design ethos that encourages extending system functionality through modules rather than through custom development. At the heart of this architecture is openness—Open APIs for seamless data exchange, Open Data Standards like OData for consistency, and transparency through visual workflow tools that let organizations customize without sacrificing usability. This is called Extensibility!


Consider the difference: instead of forcing an ERP to micromanage warehouse operations or a WMS to oversee financial accounting, imagine a scenario where each system is used for its intended purpose—a best-in-class Warehouse Management System (WMS) communicating seamlessly with an ERP, which in turn integrates with a Customer Relationship Management (CRM) platform. Each system is an expert in its own domain, but when combined through a cohesive, modern enterprise platform, they provide the complete visibility and operational excellence that businesses need. The data flows naturally, insights are accessible across the organization, and changes are made efficiently without needing Herculean customizations. Standardizing INPUTS and OUTPUTS, commonly referred to as Data Contracts, allows this interoperability between systems built by different vendors or even solutions not yet conceived. Connective Tissue at the core of a solution's design is a recipe for success.


It's time to take that Step!

The journey to an integrated enterprise is not about searching for a mythical, do-it-all solution. Instead, it's about building a foundation of specialized tools that interlock and cooperate—creating an ecosystem that is as flexible as it is functional. Event-driven workflows, OpenAPI integrations, extensible architecture, and transparent visual workflows provide a true enterprise-class platform capable of adapting to business changes, not fighting against them. Businesses will then come to see capital spent on these systems and their ecosystem as a tangible asset worthy of investment and, more importantly, a strategic advantage of how they compete in the market.


The future of enterprise technology is clear: it isn't about bending one system to try and solve every problem. It's about assembling specialized vertical components, each optimized for its own domain, built from inception to integrate, extend, and work in harmony. This composable approach promises a truly tailored operational solution, delivering on efficiency, adaptability, and ultimately the business outcomes that matter most.

5 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page